| Round 1 | |||||
| 1 |  | USSSA Florida Pride | Brittany Mack | P | LSU |
| 2 |  | Chicago Bandits | Kimi Pohlman | OF | Washington |
| 3 |  | Akron Racers | Lexy Bennett | IF | Texas |
| 4 | | USSSA Florida Pride | Andrea Harrison | OF | UCLA |
| Round 2 | |||||
| 5 |  | USSSA Florida Pride | Kristyn Sandberg | C | Georgia |
| 6 | | Chicago Bandits | Katie Schroeder | OF | UCLA |
| 7 |  | Akron Racers | Hillary Bach | P | Arizona State |
| 8 | | USSSA Florida Pride | Valerie Arioto | UTIL | California |
| Round 3 | |||||
| 9 |  | Carolina Diamonds | Sara Plourde | P | UMass |
| 10 | | Chicago Bandits | Stephanie Ricketts | P/1B | Hawaii |
| 11 | | Akron Racers | Amanda Chidester | IF | Michigan |
| 12 | | USSSA Florida Pride | Michelle Moultrie | OF | Florida |
| Round 4 | |||||
| 13 | | Carolina Diamonds | Kelsi Weseman | IF | Georgia Tech |
| 14 | | Akron Racers | Alicia Herron | IF | Ohio State |
| 15 | | Akron Racers | Jen Mineau | P | Fordham |
| 16 | | USSSA Florida Pride | Nikia Williams | UTIL | Washington |
| Round 5 | |||||
| 17 | | Carolina Diamonds | Angel Bunner | P | Auburn |
| 18 | | Chicago Bandits | Adrienne Monka | IF | Northwestern |
| 19 | | Akron Racers | Jamia Reid | OF | California |
| 20 | | USSSA Florida Pride | Christi Orgeron | UTIL | Louisiana |
