| Preseason All Independent Teams | |||
| First Team | |||
| Offense | Defense | ||
| QB | Jake Heaps, BYU | DT | Hebron Fangupo, BYU |
| RB | Cierre Wood, Notre Dame | DT | Sean Cwynar, Notre Dame |
| RB | Jared Hassin, Army | DE | Kapron Lewis-Moore, Notre Dame |
| WR | Michael Floyd, Notre Dame | DE | Eathyn Manumaleuna, BYU |
| WR | Theo Riddick, Notre Dame | LB | Manti Te'o, Notre Dame |
| TE | Devin Mahina, BYU | LB | Steven Erzinger, Army |
| OL | Matt Reynolds, BYU | LB | Darius Fleming, Notre Dame |
| OL | Braden Hansen, BYU | CB | Gary Gray, Notre Dame |
| OL | Trevor Robinson, Notre Dame | CB | Robert Blanton, Notre Dame |
| OL | Brady DeMell, Navy | S | Harrison Smith, Notre Dame |
| OL | Frank Allen, Army | S | Zeke Motta, Notre Dame |
| K | David Ruffer, Notre Dame | P | Ben Turk, Notre Dame |
| KR | Alexander Teich, Navy | PR | Josh Jackson, Army |
| Second Team | |||
| Offense | Defense | ||
| QB | Dayne Crist, Notre Dame | DT | Louis Nix, Notre Dame |
| RB | J.J. Di Luigi, BYU | DT | A.J. Mackey, Army |
| RB | Alexander Teich, Navy | DE | Ethan Johnson, Notre Dame |
| WR | McKay Jacobson, BYU | DE | Jabaree Tuani, Navy |
| WR | Cody Hoffman, BYU | LB | Brandon Ogletree, BYU |
| TE | Tyler Eifert, Notre Dame | LB | Max Blue, Navy |
| OL | Zack Martin, Notre Dame | LB | Jordan Pendleton, BYU |
| OL | Terence Brown, BYU | CB | Kwesi Mitchell, Navy |
| OL | Braden Brown, BYU | CB | Preston Hadley, BYU |
| OL | John Dowd, Navy | S | Daniel Sorensen, BYU |
| OL | Chris Watt, Notre Dame | S | Travis Uale, BYU |
| K | Alex Carlton, Army | P | Riley Stephenson, BYU |
| KR | Cody Hoffman, BYU | PR | J.D. Falslev, BYU |
| Third Team | |||
| Offense | Defense | ||
| QB | Trent Steelman, Army | DT | Romey Fuga, BYU |
| RB | Gee Gee Greene, Navy | DT | Jared Marks, Navy |
| RB | Jonas Gray, Notre Dame | DE | Matt Putnam, BYU |
| WR | Austin Barr, Army | DE | Jarrett Mackey, Army |
| WR | T.J. Jones, Notre Dame | LB | Prince Shembo, Notre Dame |
| TE | Richard Wilson, BYU | LB | Carlo Calabrese, Nore Dame |
| OL | Taylor Dever, Notre Dame | LB | Zach Watts, Army |
| OL | Braxston Cave, Notre Dame | CB | David Wright, Navy |
| OL | Ryan Basford, Navy | CB | Josh Jackson, Army |
| OL | David Sumrall, Navy | S | Tra'ves Bush, Navy |
| OL | Brad Kelly, Army | S | Jordan Fraser, Navy |
| K | Jon Teague, Navy | P | Justin Haan, Navy |
| KR | Bennett Jackson, Notre Dame | PR | Gary Myers, Navy |
| Coach of the Year | Freshman of the Year | ||
| Bronco Mendenhall | Aaron Lynch, Notre Dame | ||
| Offensive Player of the Year | Defensive Player of the Year | ||
| Michael Floyd, Notre Dame | Manti Te'o, Notre Dame | ||
FBS Independent 2011 Football Awards
Tue, 06/21/2011
