| | | | | | |
| | Madness 2016 Softball All-American Teams | |
| |  | |
| | | |
| | | | | | |
| Field Player of the Year | | Pitcher of the Year | |
| Sierra Romero, Michigan | | Kelsey Nunley, Kentucky | |
| | | | | | |
| Freshman of the Year | | Coach of the Year | |
| Amanda Lorenz, Florida | | Heather Tarr, Washington | |
| | | | | | |
| First Team | | Second Team | |
| P | Kelsey Nunley, Kentucky | | P | Kylee Hanson, Florida Atlantic | |
| P | Jessica Burroughs, Florida State | | P | Aleshia Ocasio, Florida | |
| P | Delanie Gourley, Florida | | P | Cheridan Hawkins, Oregon | |
| IF | Kasey Cooper, Auburn | | IF | Ali Aguilar, Washington | |
| IF | Sierra Romero, Michigan | | IF | Kristen Brown, North Carolina | |
| IF | Bianka Bell, LSU | | IF | Alex Powers, Florida State | |
| IF | Lexie Elkins, Louisiana | | IF | Nikki Udria, Oregon | |
| IF | Tori Vidales, Texas A&M | | IF | Jessica Warren, Florida State | |
| OF | Haylie McCleney, Alabama | | OF | Amanda Lorenz, Florida | |
| OF | Sierra Lawrence, Michigan | | OF | Erin Miller, Oklahoma | |
| OF | Emily Crane, Missouri | | OF | Allexis Bennett, UCLA | |
| UTIL | Jailyn Ford, James Madison | | UTIL | Kayli Kvistad, Florida | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| Third Team | | Fourth Team | |
| P | Megan Good, James Madison | | P | Chelsea Wilkinson, Georgia | |
| P | Megan Betsa, Michigan | | P | Sara Groenewegen, Minnesota | |
| P | Paige Parker, Oklahoma | | P | Maryssa Becker, Louisville | |
| IF | Katiyana Mauga, Arizona | | IF | Tatiana Cortez, Boston College | |
| IF | Hannah Flippen, Utah | | IF | Sarah Smith, Baylor | |
| IF | Alyssa DiCarlo, Georgia | | IF | Kimberlee Souza, Washington | |
| IF | Meghan Gregg, Tennessee | | IF | Chaley Brickey, Kansas | |
| IF | MJ Knighten, Minnesota | | IF | Shay Knighten, Oklahoma | |
| OF | Karley Wester, Notre Dame | | OF | Sydni Emanuel, Georgia | |
| OF | Koral Costa, Oregon | | OF | Cortni Emanuel, Georgia | |
| OF | Lindsey Stephens, Texas | | OF | Aleah Craighton, Louisiana | |
| UTIL | Lindsey Willmon, Fresno State | | UTIL | Juli Weber, South Florida | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
| | Softball Awards Page | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
