| | | | | | |
| | Madness 2012 FCS Football All-American Teams | |
| |  | |
| | | | | | |
| | Coach of the Year | | Freshman of the Year | |
| | Craig Bohl, North Dakota State | | Jeff Williams, Delaware | |
| | | | | | |
| | Offensive Player of the Year | | Defensive Player of the Year | |
| | DeNarius McGhee, Montana State | Colton Underwood, Illinois State | |
| | | | | | |
| First Team | |
| | | | | | |
| Offense | | Defense | |
| QB | DeNarius McGhee, Montana State | DL | Caleb Schreibeis, Montana State | |
| RB | Eric Breitenstein, Wofford | | DL | Brandon Thurmond, Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| RB | Miguel Maysonet, Stony Brook | | DL | Colton Underwood, Illinois State | |
| WR | Erik Lora, Eastern Illinois | | DL | Lebrandon Richardson, Bethune-Cookman |
| WR | Brandon Kaufman, Eastern Washington | LB | Blake Peiffer, Southeast Mo State | |
| WR | Aaron Mellette, Elon | | LB | Ian Sluss, Portland State | |
| TE | Kyle Juszczyk, Harvard | | LB | Jeremy Kimbrough, Appalachian State |
| OL | Mike Vuono, Lehigh | | LB | Stephon Robertson, James Madison |
| OL | Mike Sellers, Citadel | | DB | Darnell Taylor, Sam Houston State |
| OL | Earl Watford, James Madison | | DB | Jaquiski Tartt, Samford | |
| OL | Chris Howley, Maine | | DB | Cooper Taylor, Richmond | |
| OL | Patrick Ford, Eastern Kentucky | | DB | Marcus Williams, North Dakota State |
| K | Colton Cook, Southern Utah | | P | Andy Wilder, Northern Arizona | |
| KR | Jerodis Williams, Furman | | PR | Dominic Gunn, Northern Colorado | |
| | | | | | |
| Second Team | |
| | | | | | |
| Offense | | Defense | |
| QB | Jamal Jackson, Appalachian State | DL | Jerry Ceja, Eastern Washington | |
| RB | Tim Flanders, Sam Houston State | DL | Zach Hodges, Harvard | |
| RB | Zach Bauman, Northern Arizona | | DL | Joseph Lebeau, Jackson State | |
| WR | Nick Mayers, Old Dominion | | DL | Cole Jirik, North Dakota State | |
| WR | Cordell Roberson, Stephen F. Austin | LB | Robert McCabe, Georgetown | |
| WR | Jordan Harris, Bryant | | LB | Matt Evans, New Hampshire | |
| TE | MyCole Pruitt, Southern Illinois | | LB | Monte Gaddis, Towson | |
| OL | Aaron Adams, Eastern Kentucky | | LB | Jordan Tripp, Montana | |
| OL | Tytan Timoteo, Weber State | | DB | Nico Molino, Cal Poly | |
| OL | Kadeem Williams, Albany | | DB | Demetrius McCray, Appalachian State |
| OL | Jack Lowney, Old Dominion | | DB | Eric Loper, Villanova | |
| OL | Jack Templeton, Brown | | DB | Robert Alford, Southeastern Louisiana |
| K | Patrick Murray, Fordham | | P | Chad Zinchini, Tennessee Tech | |
| KR | Otis Wright, Wagner | | PR | Austin Shanks, Northern Arizona |
| | | | | | |
| Third Team | |
| | | | | | |
| Offense | | Defense | |
| QB | Casey Brockman, Murray State | | DL | Dion Dubose, Georgia Southern | |
| RB | Zach Zenner, South Dakota State | DL | Jeremy Stephens, Butler | |
| RB | Terrance West, Towson | | DL | Cody Larson, Southern Utah | |
| WR | Quentin Sims, Tennessee-Martin | DL | Ryan Nearhoof, Robert Morris | |
| WR | Walter Powell, Murray State | | LB | Jayson DiManche, Southern Illinois | |
| WR | Rico Richardson, Jackson State | | LB | Wes Dothard, Chattanooga | |
| TE | Faysal Shafaat, Chattanooga | | LB | Tanner Burch, Gardner-Webb | |
| OL | Mark Pratt, Youngstown State | | LB | Todd Davis, Sacramento State | |
| OL | Jamie Dunaway, Gardner-Webb | | DB | Johnny Towalid, Indiana State | |
| OL | Dorian Byrd, Georgia Southern | | DB | Blake Wylie, Wofford | |
| OL | Billy Turner, North Dakota State | | DB | Lucky Dozier, Northern Arizona | |
| OL | Cory Howard, Central Arkansas | | DB | Ben Ericksen, Illinois State | |
| K | Jimmy Pavel, Eastern Washington | P | Matt Hubbard, Georgia State | |
| KR | Greg Hardin, North Dakota | | PR | Walter Powell, Murray State | |
| | | | | | |
| FCS Football Awards Page | |
| | | | | | |
| | | | | | |
